Why MSPs Struggle to Hire Tier 2 IT Support Technicians (And What the Fastest-Growing MSPs Do Differently)

The Tier 2 Hiring Problem Most MSPs Face

For many managed service providers, growth doesn't stop because of sales.

It stops because of hiring.

A new client signs, ticket volume increases, projects stack up, and suddenly your senior engineers are spending time on issues that should never reach them.

The biggest bottleneck we see among MSPs is not finding clients—it's finding reliable Tier 2 IT Support Technicians who can handle tickets independently, communicate professionally with end users, and work during U.S. business hours.

Why Tier 2 Talent Is So Difficult to Find

MSP Experience Is Different Than Traditional IT Experience

Many candidates have technical skills.

Far fewer have MSP experience.

Working in an MSP environment requires professionals who can:

• Manage multiple clients simultaneously
• Prioritize competing requests
• Follow SLA requirements
• Document work properly
• Communicate effectively with non-technical users

A candidate may have strong technical knowledge and still struggle in an MSP environment.

Competition Is Higher Than Ever

MSPs are competing against:

• Internal IT departments
• Technology companies
• Software vendors
• Larger MSPs with bigger recruiting budgets

This creates a shrinking pool of available candidates.

Technical Skills Alone Are Not Enough

One of the most common hiring mistakes is evaluating only technical ability.

Client-facing support requires:

• Professional communication
• Ownership mentality
• Customer service skills
• Accountability
• Reliability

Without these traits, ticket resolution may improve while client satisfaction declines.

What High-Growth MSPs Do Differently

They Hire Before Capacity Becomes a Crisis

The best MSPs don't wait until SLA violations begin.

They monitor:

• Ticket backlog trends
• Engineer utilization
• Client growth forecasts
• Escalation rates

Then they hire proactively.

They Build Layered Support Teams

Instead of relying on senior engineers for everything, successful MSPs create structured support levels.

This allows:

• Tier 1 specialists to handle routine tickets
• Tier 2 technicians to resolve more complex issues
• Senior engineers to focus on escalations and projects

The result is greater efficiency and stronger margins.

They Expand Their Talent Search

Limiting hiring to a local market often creates unnecessary constraints.

Many MSPs are now building support teams with professionals throughout Latin America who work during U.S. business hours and integrate directly into internal operations.

How Romy Screens IT Support Talent

Unlike staffing firms that simply forward resumes, our process includes:

Technical Screening

Candidates are evaluated based on the requirements of the specific role and client environment.

English Communication Evaluation

Because IT support is customer-facing, communication is assessed from the first conversation.

Criteria Assessments

Candidates complete assessments measuring workplace behaviors and problem-solving capabilities.

Multiple Interview Stages

Every candidate progresses through a structured screening process before being presented to clients.

Background and Reference Verification

We verify employment history, references, and conduct background checks before placement.

The Real Cost of Delaying a Hire

Many MSP owners focus on the cost of hiring.

Few calculate the cost of waiting.

Delaying a critical support hire can lead to:

• SLA violations
• Increased engineer burnout
• Lost project opportunities
• Reduced client satisfaction
• Slower business growth

The right hire often pays for itself faster than expected.

Final Thoughts

If your senior engineers are handling routine tickets, your ticket backlog continues to grow, or your team is showing signs of burnout, the issue may not be operational.

It may be capacity.

The MSPs that scale successfully are rarely the ones that work harder.

They're the ones that build the right team before growth forces their hand.

‍